I feel like I should add a disclaimer of sorts at the beginning of this review. While reading, please be aware (wary?) that the review you are about to read was written by a die-hard fan of the Potter books, so the opinions may be a bit harsh or, at times, biased. I assure you I did my best to keep the bias to a minimum, but I can’t turn off my level of obsession! Feel free to carry on.
Experience has previously taught me to have low expectations for the Potter films. I had no complaints for Philosopher’s Stone and Chamber of Secrets, but the release of Prisoner of Azkaban had me outraged. They had completely left out the explanation behind the Marauders’ Map, ruined whatever they had left in regarding Remus Lupin, and more. Goblet of Fire was a tad better, but my opinion went down again with the release of Order of the Phoenix. Therefore, you can imagine the mindset I had going into the theatre to view Half-Blood Prince.
That movie changed everything.
Well, not everything, I suppose. I didn’t change my outlooks on Prisoner, Goblet or Phoenix, but it did change my attitude about Prince. A lot.
I was amazed that when I saw the movie, the scenes I’d seen in trailers looked more impressive, they were funnier, they were just better. This movie, as Frak from PotterCast put it, really “held hands” with Phoenix in a way that was completely natural. Having had Prisoner, Goblet and Phoenix helmed by three different directors, it was obvious that they were completely different movies. This time, it actually felt like it was the same series. The opening shot of Prince was from one of the last scenes in Phoenix. What a brilliant start to a brilliant movie.
The movie only got better from there. The movie was actually funny without having to have the actors act out of character, and for once, it was because it was the first time Steve Kloves actually decided to use lines verbatim from the books since Chamber (can anyone say “the prophecy?”). That alone transformed the movie more than I can say. Steve Kloves and David Yates (and the rest of the crew and actors) also did a fantastic job at balancing the (appropriately, might I add) light-hearted scenes with darker ones, which really made the darker scenes stand out as true accomplishments.
Something else I really loved in this film was the acting. Dan, Emma, Rupert and Tom have become such great actors. Their scenes in Prince didn’t have a forced air about them like they might have in previous films. I was quite worried about the Sectumsempra scene, but Tom pulled it off perfectly; in the common room scenes, I actually got the sense that Dan, Emma and Rupert have the same friendship that Harry, Hermione and Ron do. Alan Rickman also, yet again, was absolutely perfect as Severus Snape. His facial expressions were fittingly confused, worried, torn, etc. when the time called for it, without giving his alliance away to the movie-goer who doesn’t read the books. Kudos to you, Alan Rickman, for being so awesome.
Don’t get me wrong – this movie could still have been improved in various ways. The adult actors, as usual, did not get enough screen time, unfortunately, and though Michael Gambon’s acting was stupendous during the climax of this movie, the rest of his performance failed yet again to convince me that he was Dumbledore. Movie!Dumbledore also failed to adequately prepare Harry for finding the horcruxes. You thought he wasn’t prepared after book!Prince? Well, he’s even less prepared now. I guess they’ll just have Hermione figure things out for him, like she always does…
Though I’ve only touched on things I liked about this film (others include the Vanishing Cabinet scenes, Spinner’s End, and tons of other little details that they left in but could have just as easily discarded), I can assure you it’s the movie to see, and I’m not just saying that because I’m a Potter fan. (Ok, maybe a little.) Settle in for the best Potter film seven years.
